The people of Phana have much to be proud of. And they are right to feel pride in the cleanliness of the streets, the 'zero waste' campaign that recycles large quantities of waste; the community spirit and community action that enables campaigns such as this, initiated by the tetsaban, to succeed. And the tetsaban is rightly proud of the prizes and the national exposure and acclaim it has won.
The people of Phana are also proud of Don Chao Poo, a conservation site for more than 50 years. And proud of the long-tailed macaque monkeys that live in the forest, some 500-600 of them. The monkeys attract tourists, mostly from the surrounding villages and towns but some from further afield. After the famous Buddha image in Wat Phra Lao Thepnimit, they are what puts Phana on the map.
But there's the rub: put monkeys and tourists together and one of the things you get is litter. Tourists bring food for the monkeys, or buy it in the stalls outside the forest, and much of the food is in plastic bags. Monkeys grab plastic bags; the wind blows them around; the waste bins are a waste of time because the monkeys raid them and scatter the contents. But you can't blame the monkeys; and if the tourists should take more care and take home their litter whenever possible, at least they are being thoughtful and generous in providing food for the monkeys.
Recent trips Pensri and I have made into the forest have dismayed us both: the amount of litter is, quite frankly, disgusting. It makes a mockery of the forest as a conservation area, and it makes a mockery of Phana considering itself a clean place. Here are some pictures I have taken recently.
This one shows plastic bags that have been discarded and blown into the forest close to the track. This degree of litter should be easy to deal with if it is removed quickly, by which I mean daily or at least every other day.
But the accumulation of rubbish such as this is on another scale altogether. It is not wind-blown. It is not deposited by monkeys. Some of it is embedded in the soil, so it has been here for years, not days.
This litter has been quite deliberately collected here and it is easy to work out WHEN and WHY and WHO by.
Don Chao Poo forest is used by the tetsban and the amphur to hold official 'opening ceremonies' for a variety of occasions. Before the Governor or his representative or some other dignitary is whisked into the forest in a motorcade, the roads are 'cleaned up' -- a euphemism for brushing all the litter into the undergrowth, out of sight. Cliches, maybe, but relevant and accurate: brushing the problem under the carpet; out of sight, out of mind.
So what is to be done? Well, it is a long-term problem that will only get worse if plans to encourage more tourists to visit Phana come to anything. In the short term, Pensri and I went to the forest last Wednesday and spent about 90 minutes collecting litter. We filled 5 black bin bags in that time. We filled the first one twice because some monkeys came along and ripped it open and re-scattered the litter. A good demonstration of part of the problem. But we also saw lots of evidence that the monkeys are only part of the problem. It is not, I think, the monkeys who are drinking beer, milk, fruit juice, eating sweets, smoking cigarettes or reading and and discarding magazines full of pictures of naked women. I hope the monkeys know better than to do any of that, though I know they learn fast.
On Thursday we were joined by a friend of Pensri's and three young students from Phana Suksa. On Friday there were five young students from Phana Suksa. On those two days we collected more than 30 bags full of litter and then went to have duck noodle soup together in Ban Don Kwan.
The man in the picture here is employed by the tetsaban to spend a couple of hours a day in the forest, putting down tetsaban-provided rice for them, sweeping up some of the leaves. There is no blame attached to him for the litter: there is far too much of it for one person to deal with.
The youngsters here all wanted to continue working on the weekend but we oldies needed a rest. We will be back in the forest on Monday, but by then the weekend feeding by tourists will have introduced a lot more plastic bags. Never mind, it is likely that we will have removed the biggest proportion of the long-term litter in another two mornings of work. Then it will be up to the community to decide how to tackle the problem in a way that will make a blitz such as ours unnecessary again.
For the rest of this week I will post blogs with some of my thoughts about the 'monkey/litter problem' in Phana. I hope readers will offer some suggestions, too.
Recent Comments